Skip to content
Back to the lab

Phone versus online scheduling: the survey question can reverse the competitive story

Phone and online scheduling surveys can appear to conflict when they measure different populations, channels, usage, and preferences.

Super Genius Labs Editorial · 3 min read

A scheduling survey can change the competitive story by measuring channel use, individual preference, grouped preference, or top-three selection. Those measures answer different questions, so their percentages cannot be compared as though they describe the same choice.

One vendor-sponsored survey reports similar preference ratings for digital apps and phone calls. Another ranks combined online self-service channels above phone. The reported results can coexist because a single phone channel is not equivalent to grouped digital channels, and actual use is not equivalent to stated preference.

What each survey reports

Bandwidth reports an April 2026 survey of 1,000 U.S. adults who had recently visited a healthcare provider. It says 69.9% used phone and 59.6% used a portal, while cautioning that use reflects channel availability rather than true preference. It also reports similar preference ratings for digital apps and phone calls. Bandwidth survey

Practice Better and Stripe surveyed more than 1,000 patients. Their study reports that online self-service channels ranked first as a preferred booking method at 42%, ahead of phone at 33%. Separately, phone appeared among the top three methods used by 74% and preferred by 64%, while digital channels showed the opposite pattern. Practice Better and Stripe study

The two sources report different measurement objects. Bandwidth distinguishes observed use from preference and compares phone with a digital-app category. Practice Better combines online self-service channels for one ranking and separately reports top-three use and preference. A buyer cannot place 69.9% phone use beside 42% online preference and treat the larger number as proof of channel demand. The percentages describe different measures.

Four questions hidden inside one comparison

A scheduling statistic becomes useful only after its measurement object is clear:

  • Use: Which channels did respondents actually use?
  • Single-channel preference: Which individual channel did respondents favor?
  • Grouped preference: How did several online routes perform after being combined?
  • Top-three selection: Did a channel appear anywhere among several selected options?

These questions can produce different rankings. A high use figure may reflect what was available. A grouped online category may collect preferences that would be divided across several digital options if reported separately. A top-three result measures inclusion, not first choice.

The surveys also describe different populations and field periods. Bandwidth identifies an April 2026 sample of U.S. adults who had recently visited a healthcare provider. The supplied Practice Better excerpt identifies more than 1,000 patients and dates the study to 2025, but does not provide enough detail to establish that its sampling frame matches Bandwidth’s. These differences could also contribute to the reported results. Bandwidth survey Practice Better and Stripe study

Audit the claim before evaluating the vendor

When a scheduling or AI answering service vendor cites a channel-preference percentage, ask for the population, field period, exact question, response format, channel grouping, and whether the result measures use or preference. Then compare only figures that align on those dimensions.

A claim that “patients prefer online booking” may accurately summarize the 42% grouped online result in the Practice Better study. That result covers combined online self-service channels rather than establishing a ranking for every individual digital channel. A claim that “patients still choose the phone” may accurately describe Bandwidth’s 69.9% usage figure, which the source says is influenced by channel availability. Practice Better and Stripe study Bandwidth survey

Both sources describe continued phone use alongside meaningful demand for digital scheduling. For buyers, the useful comparison is how a vendor supports the channels the practice intends to offer and how it reports completion across them. Teams preparing that evaluation can use the broader workflow approach in Build.